France’s Migration Policy under President E. Macron: A European Dimension

This article explores the current approach of France to the issue of regulating migration in the context of Emmanuel Macron’s European diplomacy. Today the French government believes that taking part in the elaboration of a common EU migration and asylum policy is a necessary addition to the measures at home, paying particular attention to this topic since 2017. On the basis of public speeches, international documents and the elements of comparative analysis, the article summarizes the main initiatives put forward by France at European level and the challenges they faced. It points out that a part of Emmanuel Macron’s proposals regarding the governance of the Schengen area and the strengthening of the external borders control was implemented to some extent (taking into account the buildup of border capacities or the establishment of the “Schengen Council”), even if these proposals did not fully correspond to his initial project. On the contrary, France’s bilateral relations with its major neighbors (Germany, Spain, the United Kingdom or Italy) demonstrated a generally controversial dynamics because the partnerships on migration issues clearly depended on the political parties in power. In this regard, Italy, with the pro-European periods quickly followed by sovereignist shifts, looks like a particularly illustrative example. Moreover, numerous steps proposed by Paris to deal with the migration fl ows outside Europe often lacked any details and common ground with the partners. This is particularly noticeable in the African direction where French eff orts, from settling regional confl icts to restoring dialogue with Maghreb countries, produced insuffi cient results. The article concludes that from 2017 to 2023, France continued to seek balance between “responsible” and “solidarity-based” approaches to migration policy at the European level, and this would be the case until the end of current presidency. Yet, in 2027, the situation could change according to ideological preferences of Macron’s successor.

1. Alekseenkova, Elena S., and Aleksei Y. Chikhachev. “The Quirinal Treaty: Bilateral Agreement on the EU’s Future?.” Contemporary Europe, no. 3 (2022): 33–48 [In Russian].

2. Bisson, Lyubov S. “The EU’s New Strategy for Africa: In Search of a Genuine Partnership.” Contemporary Europe, no. 3 (2020): 39–50 [In Russian].

3. Vedernikov, Mikhail V. “Evropeiskie podkhody k pandemii.” In Evropa v krizisnom mire, 48–81, Moscow: Ves’ mir, 2022 [In Russian].

4. Godovanyuk, Kira A. “UK-EU New Format of Relationship: the Postbrexit Challenges.” The Herald of the Diplomatic Academy of the MFA of Russia. Russia and the World, no. 4 (2021): 54–70 [In Russian].

5. Eremina, Natalia V., and Aleksei Y. Chikhachev. “From ‘Open Door Policy’ to Migrant Crisis: the Reforming of Migration Policy in European and National Dimensions (the Examples of Great Britain and France).” Comparative Politics Russia 7, no. 4 (2016): 36–61 [In Russian].

6. Macron, Emmanuel. Revolyutsiya. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo universiteta, 2019 [In Russian].

7. Nadzharov, Alexander M. “Signifi cance of the Fezzan Region in French Policy in Libya and the Sahel.” Journal of International Analytics 14, no. 2 (2023): 166–182 [In Russian].

8. Potemkina, Olga Y. “After the Crisis: ‘A New Start’ of the EU Migration Policy.” Contemporary Europe, no. 6 (2019): 18–30 [In Russian].

9. Potemkina, Olga Y. “French Presidency in the Council of the EU: European or National Priorities?” Nauchno-analiticheskij vestnik IE RAN, no. 1 (2022): 7–16 [In Russian].

10. Rubinskiy, Yuri I., and Aleksei A. Sindeev. Evolution of the Franco-German tandem. Moscow: Institute of Europe RAS, 2023 [In Russian].

11. Streltsova, Yana R. “The Policy towards Migration of Students and Qualifi ed Staff .” In Contemporary France: between worries and hopes, 58–65. Moscow: IMEMO RAS, 2022 [In Russian].

12. Streltsova, Yana R. “Modern Migration Policy of France.” World Economy and International Relations 64, no. 8 (2020): 119–126 [In Russian].

13. Trofimova, Olga E. “The President is Search of a New Migration Policy.” In Contemporary France: between worries and hopes, 47–57. Moscow: IMEMO RAS, 2022 [In Russian].

14. Fedorov, Sergei M. “‘Macron’s Plan’ for Europe: A New Start for the European Project in XXI Century?.” Contemporary Europe, no. 6 (2018): 30–40 [In Russian].

15. Fedorov, Sergei M. “Macron’s ‘European Project’: Four Years Later (French Plans and the Realities of the European Union).” Contemporary Europe, no. 5 (2021): 68–78 [In Russian].

16. Chernega, Vladimir N. “Assertive Policy of France in Syria and Libya.” Current Problems of Europe, no. 4 (2022): 109–133 [In Russian].

17. Chistyakov, Alexei V. “Regrouping of ‘Centers of Power’ in the Fight for French Islam.” Nauchnoanaliticheskij vestnik IE RAN, no. 1 (2022): 108–116 [In Russian].

18. Chikhachev, Aleksei Y. “The Concept of the ‘Paris Consensus’ in Emmanuel Macron’s Political Discourse.” In The World After the Pandemic: Global Challenges and Prospects for Development (Global Development, iss. 23), 93–101. Moscow: IMEMO RAS, 2022 [In Russian].

19. Shumilin, Alexander I. “France: Republic against ‘Political Islam’ (Part I).” Nauchno-analiticheskij vestnik IE RAN, no. 1. (2021): 54–61 [In Russian].

20. Yashlavskii, Andrei E. “‘Islamist Separatism’ in France as a Factor of Extremism.” World Economy and International Relations 65, no. 10 (2021): 73–80 [In Russian].

21. Aulanier, Audran, and Anja Bartel. “Les demandeurs d’asile et les réfugiés en France et en Allemagne depuis 2015.” Migrations Société, no. 2 (2022): 19–35. https://doi.org/10.3917/migra.188.0019.

22. Aulanier, Audran, and Anja Bartel. “Asylum Seekers and Refugees in France and Germany since 2015.” Migrations and Society, no. 2 (2022): 19–35 [In French].

23. Bagayoko, Niagalé. “Les instruments internationaux de gestion des confl its au défi de la crise sahélienne.” Revue Défense Nationale, no. 841 (2023): 87–94 [In French].

24. Bagayoko, Niagalé. “International Instruments of Confl ict Settlement at the Challenge of the Sahel Crisis.” Revue Défense Nationale, no. 841 (2023): 87–94 [In French].

25. Bertossi, Christophe, and Matthieu Tardis. “Emmanuel Macron and the Migration Question.” In Macron, Diplomat: A New French Foreign Policy?, edited by Thomas Gomart and Marc Hecker. Etudes de l’Ifri, April 2018.

26. iplomacy: The Case of EU-Italian Cooperation with Libya.” Italian Political Science Review 52, no. 3 (2022): 328–345. https://doi.org/10.1017/ipo.2021.47.

27. Houellebecq, Michel. Soumission. Paris: Flammarion, 2015.

28. Houellebecq, Michel. Submission. Paris: Flammarion, 2015 [In French].

29. Marciacq, Florent and Le Quiniou, Romain. “French Engagement in the Western Balkans: Boosting Strategic, Political, Economic and Societal Cooperation.” Etudes de l’Ifri, February 2022.

30. Noé, Jean-Baptiste. “‘La relation franco-italienne est stratégique, mais instable.’ Entretien avec Federico Petroni.” Confl its, no. 46 (2023): 8–11.

31. Noé, Jean-Baptiste. “‘French-Italian Relations are Strategic But Unstable.’ Inteview with Federico Petroni.” Confl its, no. 46 (2023): 8–11 [In French].

32. Liga, Aldo. “Les politiques migratoires en France, en Italie et en Espagne: un système complexe d’interdépendances internes et régionales.” Etudes de l’Ifri, June 2020.

33. Liga, Aldo. “Migration Policies in France, Italy and Spain: A Complex System of Internal and Regional Interdependencies.” Etudes de l’Ifri, June 2020 [In French].

34. Onfray, Michel. Décadance: Vie et mort du judéochristianisme. Paris: Flammarion, 2017.

35. Onfray, Michel. Decadence: The Life and Death of Judeo-Christian Tradition. Paris: Flammarion, 2017 [In French].

36. Stefanini, Patrick. Immigration. Ces réalités qu’on nous cache. Paris: Robert Laff ont, 2020.

37. Stefanini, Patrick. Immigration. The Realities Hidden from Us. Paris: Robert Laff ont, 2020 [In French].